Changing the Commission or Bonus Plan, and When

Here is the uncomfortable truth about commission: you do not control your sellers' behavior, the plan does, and you probably have not read it closely. A commission plan is a set of instructions about what to sell, to whom, and how hard to try. When you change it, you change the behavior of everyone who sells. That is the point of changing it, and also the reason it is dangerous.

The acquired company's reps built their book under their rules. Their best customers are loyal partly because of the way the reps work, and the way the reps work comes from how they are paid. Understand that before you swap in your plan. Read employee retention after acquisition for the full people picture first.

Understand the plan you inherited

Get every commission and bonus plan, written or not. Find out the rates, the thresholds, the accelerators, the caps, how credit is assigned, how house accounts are handled, what happens to a rep's commission when they leave, and how disputes are settled. Ask the reps what they believe the plan says. Differences between the document and the belief are important.

Look at the result. Who earns the most, on what kind of business, with what margin? A plan that pays on revenue may reward discounting. A plan that pays on gross profit may reward careful quoting. Know what you would be disturbing.

Why not to change it right away

Reps will read any change as a pay cut until proven otherwise. In the first weeks they are also deciding whether to stay. A new plan announced at the same time as a new owner is a signal that things will get worse. Better to leave the plan in place, say so, and set a review date.

Practical reasons also favor waiting. You do not yet know which accounts are the real earners, which reps are strong, or how your own plan will fit with their pricing. A change made on guesses is a change you will have to redo.

When the change is needed

Some changes cannot wait. A plan that pays on discounted work you have decided to stop, a plan that conflicts with your pricing policy, or one that pays the same deal twice when your reps and theirs overlap. Fix those with notice and a clear explanation.

Otherwise, plan the change for the point when you have a full year of data. Introduce it at the start of a quarter or year, so it begins with a clean period. Run both plans in parallel on paper for a period so reps see the effect before it counts.

Make it fair at the edges

The hard cases are overlap and house accounts. Two reps, one customer, and one commission. Who gets credit, and for how long? The honest answer is to decide before the argument, by rule, and not case by case. For shared accounts, go to two reps on one account.

Also settle what happens to pipeline in flight. A deal a rep worked for months should not vanish into the new plan. Write a rule for deals that were open at closing and honor it.

Connect it to the whole pay picture

Commission is one piece of compensation. For base pay, benefits and the broader question of when to change anything, see changing the compensation plan after acquisition. For the effect on customers, who notice when their rep's behavior changes, see customer retention after acquisition. The captured story I keep coming back to is the veteran operator who ran thirty sellers on thirty different plans and never lost one. In my judgment, the first call with a top seller matters more than the new plan.

Sequenced list: change a commission plan without losing the sellers

Follow in order. The dates matter more than the details.

The reps who are not yours to lose

Every sales team has a few people whose book is the business. Find them in the first week and spend time with them. Ask what they like about the plan, not what they would change. They will tell you what is actually driving their behavior, and you will learn more in one hour than from a month of reports.

If you must change something for them, change it in a way that protects their earnings for a defined period, then step down or adjust in the open. Surprise is the thing that sends a top rep to a competitor with a customer list in their head.

What to watch after

Track win rate, margin, and customer retention by rep for the first two quarters under the new plan. The numbers will tell you quickly if the plan is steering behavior the wrong way. Adjust early, and explain the adjustment. Reps will accept a correction they understand.

The plan that built the book deserves some respect before you replace it.

Questions